Can a Neighbor Tear Down a Shared Fence?


If you’re a homeowner, you may have encountered situations where you share a fence with your neighbor.

While fences are meant to provide privacy and define property boundaries, disputes can arise when it comes to the ownership and maintenance of shared fences.

The Fencing Act of 1963 stresses the importance of mutual agreement and makes it illegal for a neighbor to remove a shared fence without the other property owner’s consent. The Fencing Act of 1963, emphasizes the importance of mutual agreement and cooperation in making decisions regarding shared fences.

In this article, we will explore the topic of shared fences, delve into the provisions of the Fencing Act of 1963, and discuss some frequently asked questions related to this subject. Let’s understand the concept of shared fences and the rights and responsibilities associated with them.

Understanding Shared Fences

Shared fences, also known as boundary fences, are fences that are erected between neighboring properties to mark the boundary line and provide separation between the properties.

Usually, both property owners build them together, and they position the shared fences in a way that they straddle the property line.

The Fencing Act, 1963

The Fencing Act, of 1963, is a legal framework that addresses the rights and obligations of property owners in relation to shared fences. It provides guidance on the construction, repair, and maintenance of boundary fences.

They enacted the Act to regulate fence-related issues and promote fair and equitable practices between neighboring property owners.

Under the Fencing Act, of 1963, several key provisions are relevant to shared fences:

1. Ownership and Responsibility

The Act clarifies that shared fences are jointly owned by the neighboring property owners. This means that both parties have equal rights and responsibilities in maintaining the fence.

The Act emphasizes the importance of cost-sharing and mutual agreement on repairs, alterations, or replacement of the fence.

2. Maintenance and Repair

The Fencing Act, of 1963, stipulates that we should adequately maintain shared fences to ensure their proper functioning and longevity. It outlines the responsibility of both neighbors to contribute to the maintenance and repair costs.

They encourage regular inspections and timely repairs to prevent further damage or deterioration.

3. Alterations and Removal

If a property owner wishes to make alterations to a shared fence or remove it entirely, they must obtain the consent of the neighboring property owner.

The Act promotes the idea of consensus and mutual understanding in such situations. Alterations or removal without consent can lead to disputes and legal complications.

4. Dispute Resolution

The Fencing Act, of 1963, provides a mechanism for resolving disputes related to shared fences. It encourages neighbors to engage in open communication and negotiation to reach a mutually satisfactory agreement.

In cases where resolution is not possible, we can pursue mediation or arbitration as an alternative means of resolving the dispute.

5. Legal Recourse

If disputes cannot be resolved through amicable means, the Fencing Act, of 1963, allows property owners to seek legal assistance. Consulting a lawyer specializing in property law can provide guidance based on the specific circumstances and applicable legislation.

Legal professionals can help property owners understand their rights, navigate legal complexities, and protect their interests.

Boundary (Party) Walls or Fences

Boundary (party) walls or fences refer to shared fences that not only mark the property boundary but also serve as a structural element of the properties on both sides.

They often build these types of fences to provide support or stability to the structures we attach them to, such as buildings or houses.

The classification of a shared fence as a boundary or party wall carries specific legal implications. It means that the construction, alteration, or removal of such a fence may require the consent and agreement of both property owners.

This ensures that any changes made to the fence do not compromise the structural integrity of the properties involved.

The reason behind this legal consideration is to protect the interests of both property owners and maintain the stability and safety of the structures involved. 

By requiring mutual consent for construction or modifications to boundary walls, it prevents one owner from making unilateral decisions that may negatively impact the other property owner.

Therefore, if a shared fence is considered a boundary or party wall, both property owners must communicate and agree on any changes or repairs before proceeding.

This helps establish a fair and equitable process for maintaining and altering the fence while safeguarding the interests of both parties.

The Differences Between the Fence Running Along the Property Line

  • Equal Ownership and Responsibility: When a shared fence runs along the property line, both property owners have equal ownership rights and responsibilities for the fence.
  • Shared Maintenance Costs: we expect Both neighbors to share the costs associated with maintaining the fence, including repairs, maintenance, and any necessary upgrades.
  • Joint Decision Making: Decisions regarding the fence, such as repairs, alterations, or replacement, should be made collaboratively between the neighboring property owners.
  • Boundary Marker: The fence serves as a boundary marker, clearly indicating the property line between the two neighboring properties.
  • Maintenance Agreement: It is important to establish a clear agreement or understanding between the neighbors regarding the ongoing maintenance of the fence to avoid potential disputes in the future.

However, it is essential to consult local laws to determine the precise obligations and rights.

The Fence in the Neighbor’s Yard

If the shared fence is entirely located within the neighbor’s yard, the ownership and maintenance responsibilities may differ. In some jurisdictions, we may consider the fence the sole property of the neighbor, who bears full responsibility for its maintenance.

However, neighboring property owners might still be required to contribute to the cost of repairs or replacement, depending on local laws and agreements.

The Fence in Your Yard

Conversely, if the shared fence is situated within your yard, you generally assume ownership and maintenance responsibilities. This means you are solely responsible for the upkeep and any associated costs.

However, if the fence is jointly constructed, both property owners may still have shared rights and responsibilities.

Rights and Responsibilities of Shared Fences

The rights and responsibilities concerning shared fences are typically determined by local laws, homeowner associations, or agreements between neighbors.

Some common aspects include cost sharing, maintenance responsibilities, dispute resolution, and the right to alter or remove the fence. It is crucial to understand these rights and obligations to maintain a harmonious relationship with your neighbors.

Disputes and Conflict Resolution

Despite efforts to establish clear guidelines, disputes regarding shared fences can still occur. Disagreements may arise concerning maintenance, repairs, replacement, or alterations.

In such cases, it is advisable to engage in open communication with your neighbor and attempt to reach a mutually beneficial resolution. As said, we can also pursue mediation or arbitration to settle the matter amicably.

Seeking Legal Assistance

If disputes cannot be resolved through amicable means, seeking legal advice might be necessary. A lawyer specializing in property law can provide guidance based on the specific circumstances and applicable legislation in your area.

They can help you understand your rights, navigate the legal complexities, and protect your interests.

Maintaining Good Neighbor Relations

While shared fences can sometimes lead to conflicts, it is important to remember the value of maintaining positive relationships with your neighbors.

Open communication, respect for boundaries, and a willingness to find common ground are essential. Good neighbor relations contribute to a harmonious living environment and can help prevent and resolve disputes.

Conclusion

Shared fences can be a source of disputes among neighbors, but the Fencing Act of 1963 provides a legal framework to address these issues.

The Act emphasizes the joint ownership and responsibility of shared fences, promoting cost-sharing and mutual agreement in maintenance, repairs, and alterations. It also outlines dispute resolution mechanisms, including mediation and legal recourse if necessary.

Understanding the rights and responsibilities associated with shared fences is crucial for maintaining positive neighbor relations. Open communication and a willingness to find common ground are key to preventing and resolving conflicts.

By adhering to the provisions of the Fencing Act and maintaining good neighbor relations, homeowners can navigate shared fence issues and create a harmonious living environment.

Manny Moore

Getting my hands dirty and building a place that me and my small family love is a driving factor for what I do and how I do it. I want to share what I have learned and practiced so that it is just that much easier for everyone to have another tool in their tool belt. Your home should be a place that you love and feel comfortable in and your backyard should be no different.

Recent Posts